…
8 min read

Rigpa Is Not a Witness: Understanding the Ground of Awareness and Its Expression

Explore why rigpa is not a witness in Dzogchen, and how recognizing the inseparability of awareness and its energetic expression reveals the natural state.
Rigpa Is Not a Witness: Understanding the Ground of Awareness and Its Expression

One of the subtle mistakes we can make in meditation is to confuse awareness with the witness of our experience.

As we become familiar with meditation, we learn to observe our thoughts without becoming caught up in them. We notice sensations, feelings, and perceptions as they come and go. We begin to understand that we are not simply the contents of our experience.

This understanding can bring a genuine sense of freedom. We discover that we don't have to follow every thought or become absorbed in every feeling. We can allow our experience to unfold without constantly reacting to it.

But this understanding can also introduce another form of fixation.

Instead of identifying with the content of our experience, we begin to identify with the awareness that observes it. There is a subtle sense of being someone who is aware, standing apart from everything that appears.

In Dzogchen, this is not the recognition of rigpa.

Rigpa is not a witness standing apart from experience. The ground of awareness and its unceasing energetic expression are inseparable. To recognize the natural state is not to withdraw from appearances in all their variety, but to recognize their nature.

Not this, not this

You may have heard the expression neti neti, meaning "not this, not this."

It is a useful expression for examining our relationship with experience.

A thought arises. We become involved in it, perhaps following a memory or imagining something that might happen. Before long, our attention is carried away by the story.

At some point, we notice that we are consumed in thought. We simply let go of our fixation and allow the thought to be as it is.

In Tibetan, we have the expression rang bab, to let go. Let it be as it is.

The same applies to sensations, feelings, and perceptions. We don't need to push them away or turn away from our experience. We notice when we are holding on, and we let go.

Not this, not this.

Whatever we can identify as a particular thought, sensation, or perception is not, in itself, the ground of awareness.

But there is an important distinction here. We are not using neti neti as a method of eliminating appearances until the ground is revealed. Nor are we trying to separate ourselves from everything that arises.

We are learning to recognize and let go of fixation, including fixation on the idea that there is someone standing apart from experience.

The subtle fixation of the witness

As we become more comfortable resting in meditation, we may discover a spacious, open quality of awareness.

Thoughts come and go. Feelings rise and fall. Sensations and perceptions continue to change. Everything begins to take on the quality of an illusory play of appearances, while there remains an abiding sense of being present and undisturbed.

It can seem as though we have discovered something that doesn't change, an awareness that witnesses everything.

This can be a helpful insight, particularly when we are accustomed to being carried away by habitual thinking and emotional reactions. But we need to look at it carefully.

Is there still a subtle sense of someone observing? Is awareness experienced as something separate from thoughts, sensations, and perceptions? Are we holding onto stillness or a spacious state while allowing everything else to pass by?

If so, we may have established another division within our experience.

There is the observer, and there is everything being observed.

We may no longer be caught up in the movement of thoughts, but we are still holding on to a particular relationship with experience.

This is why the recognition of rigpa cannot be reduced to simply being aware, remaining mindful, or resting as a witness.

These are useful capacities to develop, but being aware of experience is not the same as recognizing the nature of awareness.

In Dzogchen, we are learning to recognize something more fundamental: the nature of awareness itself, in which the distinction between the observer and the observed is resolved.

The ground and its energetic expression

In Dzogchen, we can distinguish between rigpa zhi, the ground of awareness, and rigpa tsal, its energetic expression.

The ground is empty, insubstantial, and naturally present. It is not something we can locate as an object within our experience, nor is it a separate observer looking out upon the world.

Its energetic expression is the unceasing display of appearances: thoughts, feelings, sensations, perceptions, and everything that arises within experience.

We make this distinction to help us understand the nature of awareness, but we should not mistake these two aspects for separate realities. The ground and its energetic expression have never been two. They are the single sphere of awareness, thigle nyagcik, indivisible from the beginning.

Consider the sky and clouds.

The sky is vast, empty, and open. Clouds arise, move, and dissolve within that openness. We can distinguish the openness of the sky from the movement of the clouds, yet the two are inseparable.

Likewise, the ground of awareness is empty, open, and spacious, while its energetic expression is the unceasing play of luminous clarity. Thoughts, sensations, perceptions, and all appearances arise as this expression.

It's the two truths all over again, applied to mind. Emptiness and clarity are inseparable. The ground is not somewhere behind appearances, nor is its luminous expression something distinct from the ground.

We might imagine that meditation means becoming like the sky, remaining spacious and undisturbed while the clouds of experience pass by. But this can leave us with the subtle sense of a witness standing apart from appearances.

In Dzogchen, we are not trying to become the sky or get rid of the clouds. We are learning to recognize the inseparability of emptiness and clarity, the ground and its unceasing expression.

This too, this too

If not this, not this helps us release fixation on appearances, we can use another expression to correct our tendency to dissociate or separate awareness from what appears.

This too, this too.

A thought arises. This too is the energetic expression of awareness.

A sensation appears. This too.

A feeling of joy, sadness, fear, or uncertainty arises. This too.

Even the restless movement of the mind, with its endless stream of memories, expectations, and imagination, is not something separate from the ground.

But we need to be careful here.

This too does not mean that we should identify with everything that arises. Nor does it mean that every experience, simply because it appears, is itself the recognition of rigpa.

We are not replacing one form of identification with another. We are correcting the mistaken view that awareness exists apart from its expression.

When we establish ourselves as a witness, we subtly divide experience into two: awareness on one side and appearances on the other.

This too releases that division.

We can allow everything to arise naturally, without grasping at appearances or separating ourselves from them.

This is not a movement from recognizing the ground to subsequently recognizing its expression. Both not this and this too are ways of correcting mistaken views that can arise in meditation.

The point is the direct recognition of the natural state.

There is only one place of freedom

In Garab Dorje's Three Statements that Strike the Vital Point, he says:

There is your own nature, and there is the perception of other things. The two united, that is recognition.

There is our own nature, the ground of awareness. And there is the perception of other things, the unceasing display of appearances.

The two united, that is recognition.

This is not a union we need to create through meditation. It is the inseparability of the ground and its expression, which has always been our true nature.

Garab Dorje goes on to say:

When you recognize your own nature, you recognize the ground. Thus it is like a mother meeting her child. It is the recognition that there is but one sole place of freedom.

The image of a mother meeting her child suggests an immediate familiarity. There is nothing foreign to discover, nothing that needs to be constructed or manufactured.

The ground is our own nature and the one place of freedom.

Garab Dorje continues:

Outer appearances are resolved in yourself. Your self-experience is resolved in one thing only. Doubts are resolved in openness and freedom.

Consider what he is pointing out here.

Outer appearances are resolved in yourself. The world of appearances is not something standing apart from awareness, belonging to a separate realm of experience. The energetic expression of awareness, rigpa tsal, is resolved in the ground of awareness, rigpa zhi.

Your self-experience is resolved in one thing only. Even the subtle sense of being someone who experiences cannot be established as something separate from the ground. There is no independent witness to hold on to. Everything is resolved within the single sphere of awareness, thigle nyagcik.

Doubts are resolved in openness and freedom. When the distinction between awareness and its expression is resolved, there is nothing further we need to establish or defend. Everything is liberated upon arising, free in its own place.

This is the meaning of there being one sole place of freedom.

We don't need to find liberation somewhere apart from our experience. We don't need to withdraw into stillness or preserve a state of spacious awareness while the world continues around us.

The ground and its unceasing expression are inseparable.

If you've followed along with me this far, then this is where we begin to understand rangdrol, natural liberation or self-liberation.

Thoughts and appearances are liberated in their own place. There is no need for a separate observer to manage their arising and dissolution.

When we recognize the natural state, appearances do not need to be rejected, suppressed, or transformed into something else. There is nothing to purify.

Everything that arises is the energetic expression of awareness, naturally free in its own place.

Resting in the natural state

So, what does this mean for our meditation?

When we notice that we have become caught up in thoughts, we let go.

When we find ourselves trying to maintain a peaceful or spacious state, we let go of that too.

When we discover a subtle sense of being the observer, standing apart from experience, we don't have to reject the witness or try to replace it with greater clarity or adding something to our experience.

We can simply let go.

Rang bab. Let it be as it is.

The instruction is simple, but we should not confuse the act of letting go with the recognition of rigpa. Letting go can release the fixation that distracts us from our nature, but recognition requires becoming familiar with the natural state itself.

Through the direct introduction and careful guidance of a teacher, we learn to recognize the ground and continue in that recognition.

Then the movement of thoughts, feelings, and perceptions need not interrupt our meditation. Appearances arise as the energetic expression of awareness, without needing to be suppressed, purified, or transformed. Everything is resolved within awareness itself.

And this understanding is not confined to sitting meditation.

As we become familiar with the natural state, we learn to continue in pure presence amid the activities of daily life. Walking, speaking, working, thinking, and relating to others are no longer necessarily departures from that presence.

The unceasing play of life is not separate from the energetic expression of awareness.

Not this. This too.

We can use these two expressions to remind ourselves of the subtle ways fixation arises.

When we become absorbed in a thought, sensation, or feeling, neti neti, not this, not this reminds us to release our grasping.

When we find ourselves standing apart as the witness, this too reminds us that appearances are not separate from awareness.

Neither expression is the realization itself.

They are corrections to the mistaken ways we relate to experience. Once their purpose has been served, we can let them go as well.

The point of Dzogchen is to recognize the ground of our being and become familiar with that recognition, without separating the ground from its unceasing energetic expression.

There is nothing we need to hold on to, nothing we need to push away, and nowhere else we need to go.

The ground and its expression have never been two. Rigpa, awareness itself, is the naturally liberated state.

Rest naturally in that state.